Menu
Media

Home / Media  / Quotes

SEBI proposes tax relief on mutual fund switches; how NPS, ULIPs are taxed

The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) has proposed exempting mutual fund switches from capital gains tax if investors have held the units for more than one year, according to a Reuters report citing two sources familiar with the matter. If implemented, the proposal could make portfolio rebalancing easier and bring mutual funds closer to the tax treatment available under the National Pension System (NPS) and Unit Linked Insurance Plans (ULIPs).

Currently, switching from one mutual fund scheme to another is treated as a redemption of units in the existing scheme, followed by a fresh investment in the new scheme. This means investors may have to pay capital gains tax even when the money remains invested within the mutual fund ecosystem.

How will proposed tax-free mutual fund switches benefit investors?

The most direct benefit of the proposal is that investors would no longer have to pay tax merely for repositioning their investments. At present, an investor who switches from one equity fund to another after holding the units for a year pays long-term capital gains tax at 12.5% (plus applicable surcharge and cess) on gains exceeding Rs 1.25 lakh in a financial year, under Section 198 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 (corresponding to Section 112A of the erstwhile Income-tax Act, 1961). In the case of non-equity schemes, tax may be levied at slab rates or at 12.5%, depending on the nature of the fund and the holding period.

“Once the tax is paid, the amount available for reinvestment in the new scheme is reduced. The proposed relief would allow the entire corpus, including the accumulated gains, to continue compounding in the new scheme. Over long investment horizons, the difference in terminal value can be meaningful," said Mohit Gupta, Partner, PNAM & Co. LLP.

Experts suggest the proposal could also encourage disciplined portfolio rebalancing, such as shifting equity investments towards debt or hybrid funds as investors approach their financial goals. However, exit loads and other transaction costs may continue to apply.

How are mutual fund switches different from NPS and ULIPs?

Unlike mutual funds, NPS and ULIPs already allow investors to switch between their underlying investment options without triggering capital gains tax at the time of switching.

Ankit Jain, Partner, Ved Jain and Associates, pointed out that mutual funds currently face a tax disadvantage compared with these products. In mutual funds, switching between schemes, including moving from a regular plan to a direct plan of the same scheme, is treated as a taxable transfer. However, NPS and ULIPs function as umbrella investment products, allowing investors to rebalance their portfolios without immediate tax implications.

"Within an NPS Tier-I account, subscribers can change their asset allocation across Equity, Corporate Bonds, and Government Securities up to four times a financial year, and switch Pension Fund Managers once a year, with complete tax immunity," Jain explained.

Similarly, ULIP policyholders can switch between equity and debt funds without any tax liability during the policy term. However, the tax exemption on maturity proceeds is subject to conditions, including the annual premium threshold of Rs 2.5 lakh for policies issued on or after February 1, 2021.

Rajesh H Gandhi, Partner, Deloitte, highlighted that the proposed change could bring mutual funds closer to the tax treatment available under NPS and ULIPs.

"SEBI's proposal would bring mutual funds closer to the tax treatment available under NPS and ULIPs," he said.

However, investors should remember that tax-free switching does not mean tax-free withdrawal. Gains from mutual funds may still be taxable at the time of final redemption, while NPS withdrawals and ULIP maturity proceeds are governed by their respective tax provisions.

What should investors check before switching mutual funds, NPS and ULIPs?

Investors should not make switching decisions solely to save tax. The choice should be guided by financial goals, asset allocation, risk appetite and the costs involved.

Jain advised investors to use the existing tax provisions carefully while the proposed relief is still under consideration.

He also cautioned that exit loads, Securities Transaction Tax (STT) and stamp duty may continue to apply even if the proposed tax relief is implemented. Investors should avoid frequent switching based on short-term market movements.

Gupta said investors should evaluate the tax implications of a switch based on the nature of the fund, holding period and applicable capital gains tax.

"Investors should distinguish between the tax implications of switching investments and those arising at the time of final redemption, withdrawal or maturity," Mohit Gupta noted.

For NPS subscribers, Amit Kumar Maheshwari, Managing Partner, AKM Global advised keeping track of prescribed switching limits and investment restrictions, along with the tax implications of eventual withdrawals and annuity income.

"In the case of ULIPs, policyholders should check the number of free switches available and whether their policies qualify for tax exemption at maturity. The five-year lock-in period and applicable policy charges should also be considered," Maheshwari said.

 

Please click here to view the full article on Money Control.